THE HIDDEN COST OF CHASING FRANKING CREDITS

How a $1 million investor could have missed out on nearly $450,000 in just three years.

WHAT A $1 MILLION INVESTMENT LOOKED LIKE OVER THE LAST 3 YEARS

Starting Investment: $1,000,000

Investment Option Value After 3 Years
S&P Global 500 Index $1,806,954
S&P/ASX 200 Index $1,313,550
S&P/ASX 200 + Estimated Franking Credits $1,361,041

 

  • Key Takeaways

  • S&P Global 500 finished with approximately $1.81 million

  • Australian shares finished with approximately $1.31 million

  • Estimated franking credits added approximately $47,000

  • Even after allowing for franking credits, the difference remained approximately $445,913

 

Are Franking Credits Causing Australian Investors to Miss Out on Global Returns?

Franking credits are one of the great advantages available to Australian investors.

For retirees, SMSFs and pension account investors, franking credits can boost income, improve tax outcomes and increase overall returns.

However, many Australians make a subtle investment mistake known as home-country bias.

Home-country bias occurs when investors overwhelmingly invest in companies based in their own country, despite having access to investment opportunities around the world.

This is particularly common in Australia, where many investors build portfolios heavily concentrated in banks, miners and high-dividend shares to maximise franking credits.

The problem is that Australia represents only around 2% of the global share market.

Investor should really ask themselves:

Are franking credits becoming more important than total investment returns?

Over the three years to 30 October 2026, the difference between Australian and US share market returns has been substantial.

Using broad market indices, the S&P 500 delivered returns of approximately 21.81% per annum, while the S&P/ASX 200 returned approximately 9.52% per annum.

What did this mean for a real investor with $1 million?

$1,000,000 invested in the S&P 500 grew to approximately $1.81 million

  • $1,000,000 invested in the S&P/ASX 200 grew to approximately $1.31 million
  • Difference: approximately $493,000

Many Australian share investors will rightly point out that this comparison ignores dividends and franking credits.

Let’s allow for that.

Assume:

  • Dividend yield of approximately 4.0% per annum
  • 80% of dividends are fully franked
  • Full utilisation of franking credits within superannuation pension phase
  • This could provide an additional benefit of roughly 1.3% per annum.

Applying that benefit increases the effective return from 9.52% to approximately 10.82% per annum and the new figures are:

  • $1,000,000 invested in the S&P/ASX 200 and accounting for imputation credits grew to approximately = $1,361,041

Even after allowing for franking credits, the difference remains approximately:

  • $445,913

In other words, franking credits may have added around $47,000 over the three-year period, but the gap in market performance was almost half a million dollars.

This does not mean Australian shares are poor investments and should not feature in your portfolio.

Australian shares continue to play an important role in many portfolios. They provide attractive income, exposure to strong companies and valuable tax benefits through franking credits.

The issue arises when investors hold most or all of their wealth in Australia simply because they are chasing franking credits.

Australia’s Market Is Smaller Than Many Investors Realise

Australia is a fantastic place to live, but it is a very small investment market.

Australian shares represent only around 2% of the global share market.

The Australian market is also heavily concentrated in a handful of sectors, particularly:

  • Banks
  • Financial Services
  • Mining
  • Resources

By focusing almost exclusively on Australian shares, investors may miss exposure to thousands of companies operating in industries that are under-represented or virtually absent in Australia, including:

  • Technology
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Semiconductors
  • Global Healthcare
  • Consumer Brands
  • Advanced Manufacturing

Think about some of the world’s largest businesses.

  • Apple
  • Microsoft
  • NVIDIA
  • Amazon
  • Alphabet (Google).
  • None are Australian companies.

Yet some Australian investors have little or no exposure to them.

The lesson is simple.

Franking credits should be viewed as a bonus, not the primary reason for building an investment portfolio.

A well-diversified portfolio focuses on total return, risk management and long-term wealth creation. Tax benefits matter, but they should never outweigh sound investment principles.

Because in retirement, investors don’t spend franking credits, they spend the value of their portfolio.

 

Are you earning franking credits at the expense of diversification?

Book a complimentary 15-minute consultation for an initial discussion about your investment strategy and retirement goals.

📅 Book a complimentary initial call: Schedule a Time Here

Alternatively email us at: info@collinfoxfp.com.au

 

Source: https://www.spglobal.com/en

 

General Advice Warning: The information in this article and the links has been prepared for general information purposes only and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. It is not intended to provide commercial, financial, investment, accounting, tax or legal advice. You should, before you make any decision regarding any information, strategies, or products mentioned in this article, consult a professional financial advisor to consider whether it is suitable and appropriate for you and your personal needs and circumstances. Before making a decision to acquire a financial product, you should obtain and read the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) relating to that product, together with the Target Market Determination (TMD). Past performance does not predict future performance.